Under the microscope - the retail tenancy market in Australia

Author: Craddock Murray Neumann Lawyers

Publish Date: Oct 02, 2008

The Productivity Commission has just released its report, “The Market for Retail Tenancy Leases in Australia”. The Commission’s inquiry stemmed from issues arising from the growing concerns of small businesses that elements of the market for retail leases were being distorted, resulting in the exploitation of tenants.

The Commission recommends that the States and Territories examine the potential to relax planning and zoning controls that limit competition and restrict retail space. The Commission also recommends that the State government:

  • Encourage the use of simple (plain English) language in all tenancy documentation;
  • Provide clear and obvious contact points for information on lease negotiation, lease registration and dispute resolution;
  • Encourage a one-page summary of all key lease terms and conditions to be included in retail lease documentation;
  • Encourage the development of a national reference lease with a set of items (and terminology) to be included in all retail tenancy leases and in tenant and landlord disclosure statements;
  • Institute nationally consistent reporting by administering authorities on the incidence of tenancy enquiries, complaints and dispute resolution;
  • Remove those key restrictions in retail tenancy legislation that provide no improvement in operational efficiency, compared with the broader market for commercial tenancies.

Some key points from the Commonwealth government’s response include:

  • Simple language (plain English) in tenancy documentation would improve understanding of contractual obligations by parties to a lease and contribute to more effective decision-making by a tenant/prospective tenant;
  • Improved access to information would enhance the effectiveness of decision-making, increase understanding of contractual obligations and reduce incidence of disputes;
  • A one page summary of key lease terms may improve awareness of lease requirements to a prospective tenant, however tenants may solely rely on information contained in the summary and may not fully understand their contractual obligations under the terms of the lease;
  • A key set of items (and terminology) to be included in retail tenancy leases might improve transparency of lease obligations, particularly for new entrants to the market;
  • Nationally consistent reporting would enable comparisons across jurisdictions and aid evaluation of the operation of dispute resolution processes and the nature and causes of disputes which, in turn, may lead to further improvements to transparency in the market;
  • Restrictive clauses should not be removed. The key differentiation between retail and commercial tenancies is the importance of location for retailers, and the current legislation provides important protections in this respect.

Back
Book An Appointment Make an Enquiry
A member of our legal team will contact you as soon as possible
*
*
*
Brief description of enquiry:
Type the characters below:
*
Visual verification Refresh Image

a: Level 3, 131 York Street, Sydney NSW 2000 | p: 02 8268 4000 | f: 02 8268 4001 | e: craddock@craddock.com.au
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult a lawyer for individual advice regarding your own situation.
Copyright © 2006-2008 by Craddock Murray Neumann Lawyers. View our Privacy Statement